Equally important to the model and
design of sampling, is the type of study
we intend to perform. A panel study would be most
appropriate for this study
because it would allow us to examine the same set of
people each time we
visited the schools. From our literature review,
we learned that such a study
would allow us to analyze overall trends in a student's
academic performance,
using different means of measurement, and it would show
the precise patterns
of persistence and change in the student's home.
By studying the same students over time, we will be able to follow the
specific problems that arise both at
home and in school, and how that combination affects
the students' academic
performance and overall excellence.
However, as Marsh recorded, with a
panel study there is a potential danger, known as panel attrition (1990).
He explained how throughout the course of
a year, several students may relocate or transfer to
other schools. Some students who participate in the first study may
not be able to participate in the study later on in the year. Similarly,
we are concerned that students may get bored withparticipating in the study
and choose to exit the study. The danger is that those who offer
a motivational incentive throughout the study in order to keep students
interested and willing to participate.Thus far in the plan, we do not believe
that there is any possibility that our research will harm those students
who will participate in the study. Although, we can guarantee that
no physical harm will be caused, some students may get emotional when asked
questions about their family, the structure of the family, and what goes
on at home.
However, "[a]ny study attempting to
imply causation on the basis of
correlation must be interpreted carefully. The
results of the present
investigation is based on a single cohort of students
of similar age.
Researchers often find that children from different family
configurations differ on a wide variety of academic, attitudinal, and behavioral
outcomes. There is
seldom any adequate basis for determining whether these
differences are
preexisting or are caused by family configuration changes,"
---unknown.