There have been several studies done which have researched
and tested the
correlation between family structure and academic excellence.
In our
research, we found that there were frequent references
to a study, the
Beginning School Study (BSS). The BSS gathered
longitudinal information,
starting in 1982, from children entering the first grade
as well as from there
parents, regarding grades, test scores, and other school
performance measures,
plus demographic information about parents' attitudes
and activities. One
article, written by Entwisle and Alexander (2000), was
organized along the
lines of two basic questions about family structure and
children's schooling:
(1) What kinds of differences in school outcome
are associated with different
family structures? and (2) what are the mediating
factors? Entwisle and
Alexander used the BSS as the basis for their research.
Cognitive and non
cognitive outcomes for BSS children over the first five
years of school were
compared in three kinds of families: children who
live with their mother and
father, children whose single mothers share residences
with other adults who
are not the children's fathers, and children whose single
mothers maintain
residences by themselves. Possible mediators of
the effects of single parenting were also examined, including economic
and psychological resources.
socialization for school, family size and living arrangements,
parental
expectations regarding schooling, parental actions, and
social ties.
A study done by John Fantuzzo, Erin Tighe, Stephanie Childs
(1994),
developed and evaluated the Family Involvement Questionnaire
(FIQ), a
multidimensional scale of family involvement in early
childhood education.
The FIQ was guided by theory and constructed with parent
and teachers in
preschool, kindergarten, and first grade programs in
a large urban school
district. Demographic and FIQ data were collected
from 641 parents. Factor
analyses revealed three involvement constructs:
school based involvement,
home school conferencing, and homebred involvement.
Multivariate analyses
have demographic and program differences in these constructs
revealed that there were higher levels of home school conferencing and
home base involvement in two parent families than in single parent households.
A study conducted in Germany by Stecher (1997), found
that schooling
enjoyment remained unaffected by family structure, it
was influenced by the
parent child relationship. Between 1993 and 1995,
305 German children,
ages 10-13, from single and two parent families were
interviewed to explore
the relationship between a child's attitude toward learning
and schooling and
the variable of family structure and parent child interaction
quality. Structural deficit, family process, and a model combining
the two perspectives were
considered as predictors of possible outcome. However,
family structure had
an indirect effect in that the quality of parent child
interaction was higher in
two parent than in single parent families.
Battle and Scott (1996), wrote about the relationship
of children in mother
only versus father only households. Their findings
demonstrated that (1)
parental configuration is not nearly as important as
socioeconomic status and
(2) in 12th grade, African American male students
in mother only households
outperform their counterparts in father only households
and (3) parental
configuration differences disappear when socioeconomic
status is held
constant.
Anecdotal comparisons of children from "intact" and single
parent homes may
be biased. Guttman, Geva, and Gefen (1988) find
that teachers and students
are more likely to report that the child shown in a film
exhibits academic,
social, and emotional problems if they are told the child's
parents are divorced than if they are told the child comes from an "intact"
home. As Guttman,
Geva, and Gefen warn, stereotypes about "broken homes"
may adversely
affect children: Well-adjusted children from healthy
single parent homes may
"live down" to the low academic expectations of school
staff. Also, troubled
children from single parent homes may have their emotional
problems falsely
attributed to their family structure, while the actual
source of their difficulties, which may be centered in parenting practices,
neighborhood environment, or school climate -- May never be identified
and addressed. Does family
structure influence achievement? It makes intuitive
sense that (holding
parenting skills, support systems, and other background
factors constant) two
parent homes might tend to offer more resources, role
models, and adult
supervision than single parent homes. It also appears
obvious that adolescents
should delay parenthood until they are ready for child
rearing responsibilities. However, we should be cautious about making
generalizations regarding the
severe effects of single parenthood or divorce on children.
Many researchers
may fail to control adequately for the influence of parental
education, age, or
socioeconomic status, and they may fail to consider the
impact of stigma.
Furthermore, we must keep in mind that "non-two-parent
household" refers to
a variety of family configurations that range from foster
care placements to
isolated single parent families to single parent families
connected to -- and
sometimes living with -- multi-generational networks
of relatives.
We realize that Socio-Economic Status (SES) is a very
important variable to
be considered, as it was included in most of the literature
that we researched.
In order to acknowledge SES without introducing it as
a variable in our
hypothesis, we tried to control it by sampling students
who only live in the
South side of Bethlehem; an area where the variance of
income, from family
to family, is assumed to be common and stable.