[1A] (20 points) EFFECTIVE RATES Solution
To finance the purchase of a really, really nice car, Emily has the choice of two $100,000 loans from the dealer. Loan A would require 4 years
of equal monthly payments of $2,633.38 Loan B would require 24 monthly payments of $1,633.38 followed by 24 monthly payments of
$3,633.38 and one balloon payment of $5,000 at the end (on the same day as the last $3,633.38 payment).
{a} Calculate the EAR of both loans
{b} Calculate the total payments of both loans
{c} Which loan should Emily take and why?
[1B] (10 points)
While driving in your car you hear on your cheap AM staticky radio a new reporter say that “Last month prices fell by &%$#! per cent.
This is an annual rate of deflation of 18%.” You quickly pull safely off the road, whip out your financial calculator and calculate last month’s price decline as ????
[2] (20 points) EFFECTIVE RATES Solution
Today (February 23, 2010) you retire and take your $1,000,000 pension
with you. You invest it today with an insurance company that gives you
two choices: Plan A lets you take out $60,000 every six months starting
today and continuing for 10 years (last withdrawal would be August
23, 2019). The withdrawals are the beginning and middle of each year. Plan
B would be similar except that the first 10 semi-annual withdrawals would
be $90,000 and the last 10 would be only $25,000 each.
{a} Calculate the APR and EAR of each plan.
{b} Ignoring the time value of money for a minute, calculate the total
amount withdrawn from both plans.
{c} Which plan do you choose and why?
[3] (40 points) TIME VALUE OF MONEY Solution
Starting on October 5, 1990, Emily makes the first of 6 annual deposits of $D (through October 5, 1995) in order to save for her retirement.
She expects to earn 15% interest through October 5, 1995 when she expects the interest rate to decline to 8% a year for ever. The deposits must be of sufficient size to enable
Emily to make 20 planned withdrawals of $W starting on October 5, 2010. On October 5, 2010 (today) when she goes to her bank to make the first withdrawal
she discovers the bank made a big mistake and never lowered the interest rate and it’s always been 15%.
Emily thinks “Wow!” instead of $W, I can now withdraw $197,909 a year for 20 years starting today if the bank doesn’t find out and doesn’t lower my rate.
{a} Calculate D
{b} Calculate the W she was originally planning on
{c} Suppose the bank does find out and does lower her rate to 8% starting today. Instead of using the funds for her retirement, how much could she give Lehigh each year in perpetuity starting today?
[4] (30 points) TIME VALUE OF MONEY Solution
In order to save for your retirement, today (February 23, 2010) you
make the first of what you expect to be 18 equal annual deposits (last
one is February 23, 2027). The deposits must be of sufficient size to enable
you to withdraw $100,000 per year for 20 years starting on February 23,
2027) – the same day as the last deposit). You expect that your investment
will earn 8% a year until February 23, 2027 and then you expect that you
will have to move your funds to another account that pays only 6% a year.
You start making the deposits as planned but on February 23, 2016 and
2021 you have to skip those two deposits but you make all of the rest.
Everything else goes according to plan. You make the first four planned
withdrawals. Just after you make the fourth withdrawal (February 23, 2030,
it hits you that you are not going to have enough of a nest egg to make
it because of the two deposits you skipped.
You make a quick call to your rich nephew and ask for a lump sum that
day to make up for the short fall. How much must the nephew send you on
February 23, 2030 so that you can make all of the remaining planned withdrawals?
[5] (30 points) CAPITAL BUDGETING Solution
Emily Industries, Inc. is considering replacing a piece of equipment with a newer, more efficient model. The existing equipment was purchased 5 years
ago for $45 and is being depreciated using straight line to a salvage value of $0 over an originally expected life of 15 years.
The firm could sell the existing equipment today for $36. The proposed new equipment has a purchase price of $85 and would be depreciated using straight line to a salvage
value of $5 over an expected life of 10 years. The new machine would require additional net working capital of $8.6.
The firm has a marginal tax rate of 40% and a required return of 6%.
Emily estimates that the new equipment would increase annual sales by $12 and increase annual operating expenses by $4 in every year
except for the 6th year. In year 6 the firm would need to do a major overall on the equipment so total operating expenses would increase by $20 (or $14 plus the normal $6).
Calculate the replacement’s IRR. Should they replace the old equipment?
[6] (30 points) CAPITAL BUDGETING Solution
Emmo’s is contemplating replacing an existing piece of equipment with
an newer model. The existing machinery was purchased 6 years ago for $780.
It is being depreciated over an original life of 15 years to a $30 salvage
value. It can be sold today for $300.
Emmo’s expects that the new equipment will decrease annual operating
expenses by $150 and have no effect on sales. The replacement would require
additional net working capital of $72. Emmo’s uses the straight-line method,
has a marginal tax rate of 40% and has a required hurdle rate of 15%.
The firm is unsure of how much it will have pay for the new equipment.
Their policy is to depreciate this type of equipment over a 9 year life
to a salvage value of 10% of the original price.
Calculate the maximum amount Emmo’s would be willing to pay for the
new equipment.
[6.5] (20 points) CAPITAL BUDGETING
{a} Briefly explain why the assumed reinvestment of the NPV or IRR
method is better than the assumed reinvestment rate of the other one and
why this leads to a preference for one over the other.
{b} Assume you calculate the NPV of a project using straight-line depreciation.
If you were to recalculate it again using an accelerated method (such as
MACRS or double declining balance) what would happen to the NPV and why?
(Hint: what is happening to the timing of the cash flows?)
[7] (40 points) CAPITAL BUDGETING UNDER RISK Solution
Mags, Inc. is a firm operating in a single line of business. It is
planning to purchase a new piece of machinery. The cost of the project
is $1,400 and the equipment would be depreciated using the straight-line
method to a $200 salvage value over a life of 6 years. The firm's marginal
tax rate is 35% and additional net-working-capital of $150 would be required.
Below are the forecasts of the expected change in sales revenues less
expenses for each year:
40% chance of $680 per year |
20% chance of $880 per year |
40% chance of $1480 per year |
The risk-free rate of interest is 3%. The project has a beta coefficient of 2.5. The market's risk premium is 6%. The firm also found the table below from an old copy of a Fin 125 exam that may or may not prove useful: If and when you use the table, apply your a to all cash flows, both operating and non-operating.
Coefficient of Variation of CF | 0 - .20 | .21 - .40 | .41 - 65 | .66 - 1.0 | 1.01+ |
Certainty Equivalent Coeff (a) |
{a} The missing (a)’s are .5, .3, .9, .7,
and .8. Put them in the right order in the chart before you use the chart.
Read parts {b} and {c} before proceeding.
{b} Compute the NPV assuming the actual life is 4 years and the equipment
can be scrapped at that time for $300. Repeat assuming an actual life of
15 years and no scrap value (keep your same a) and assume any remaining
book value is taken as depreciation in the 7th year.
{c} Now repeat the two NPV calculations assuming that Mags is very
diversified across several different businesses.
[8] (49 points) CAPITAL BUDGETING UNDER RISK Solution
Asics Corp. is considering purchasing a new piece of equipment for
$50. It would be depreciated over a 4-year life to a salvage value of $10
using the straight-line method. Additional net-working capital of $5 would
be needed. The firm has a marginal tax rate of 50%. In addition, the risk-free
rate of interest is 4%, the market risk-premium is 5% and the equipment
beta is 1.4. The firm has made the following forecasts of the annual change
in sales minus operating costs if the equipment is purchased:
40% chance of $30 per year |
40% chance of $70 per year |
20% chance of $150 per year |
The following table may or may not be useful:
Coefficient of Variation of CF | 0 - .40 | .41 - .80 | .81 - 1.20 | 1.21+ |
Certainty Equivalent Coeff (a) |
Fill in the gray cells with these values (in the right order, of course):
.8, .3, .5, .9.
Use an a of 1.0 for any non-operating cash flows.
{a} Assume that the firm is diversified across a wide-range of industries.
Calculate the NPV of the purchase assuming an expected life of 7 years
(assume any remaining book value would be taken as a single depreciation
charge in year 5). Then calculate the NPV assuming an expected life of
only 2 years and that the firm can sell the equipment at the end of the
second year for $18.
{b} Repeat the two NPV calculations assuming that the firm operates
in a single line of business.
{c} In which scenario {a} or {b} is unsystematic risk a factor? What
happens to it in the other scenario? Give two examples of unsystematic
risk.
[9] (25 points) RISK PREMIUMS AND BOND VALUATION
Solution
Bond S is a 20-year straight, nonconvertible bond with a $1,000 par
value and an annual coupon rate of 16%, payable semi-annually. It’s currently
selling for $892.43..
Bond C is a 20-year convertible bond of the same company with a $1,000
par value and an annual coupon rate of 12%, compounded semi-annually. It
is convertible into the company’s common stock at a conversion price of
$20 per share.
{a} Calculate Bond S’s yield to maturity.
{b} Suppose the (annual) yield premium between bonds C and S is currently
2.5%. Calculate the current price of bond C.
{c} Calculate your IRR (expressed as an EAR) if you buy Bond C at its
current price and convert it 6 years later when the price of the stock
is $26 per share.
{d} What would likely happen to the current yield premium if the long-term
outlook for some of the company’s main products became brighter. Why?
[10] (25 points) RISK PREMIUMS - YIELD CURVE
{a} Draw a downward sloping term structure of interest rates and label
both axes
{b} What does the shape of the graph suggest about market expectations
of future interest rate movements? Explain what a risk premium is and why
one exists between the long-term bond and short-term bonds. Clearly explain
your answer.
{c} From the point of view of an issuer, what are the advantages and
disadvantages of issuing long-term and issuing short-term securities, given
this term structure?
[11] (15 points) RISK PREMIUMS AND BOND VALUATION Solution
Explain the concept of a risk premium as it applies to a firm’s long-term
subordinated debentures vs. its long-term mortgage bonds. Why does the
premium exist in the example that follows below?
Calculate the risk premium between Bond S and Bond M; both bonds have
a par value of $1,000. Bond S is a subordinated debenture that matures
in 30 years. Its annual coupon rate is 8%, payable semi-annually, and it
is currently selling for $1059.34. Bond M is a mortgage bond that also
matures in 30 years. Its annual coupon rate is 9.5%, payable semi-annually,
and it is currently selling for $1,484.32.
Explain what is likely to happen to the premium as the outlook for
the economy begins to improve and why
DUE TO NUMBERING SYSTEM THERE IS NO PROBLEM 12
[13] (12 points) RISK PREMIUMS AND BOND VALUATION Solution
Ten years ago you bought a bond ($1,000 par, 15 year maturity and 6%
annual coupon rate) for $987.65.
{a} If the coupon is paid semi-annually, find the yield to maturity
(EAR).
{b} You sell it today when the yield on comparable bonds is 5% per
year compounded semi-annually. Find the IRR (EAR) you earned over the holding
period.
[14] (35 points)BOND VALUATION Solution
Today Nylon, Inc. issues new 25-year subordinated debentures. The $1,000
par value bonds have an annual coupon rate of 12%, payable semi-annually
and are callable at a call price of $1075 after 5 years. They also convertible
into Nylon’s common stock at a price of $25 a share. The bonds are issued
for $1,015.98.
PARTS {b} – {e} ARE INDEPENDENT OF EACH OTHER
{a} What is a subordinated debenture?
{b} You buy a bond today. What’s your yield to maturity?
{c} You hold the bond for 6.5 years and sell it in the open market.
If the yield to maturity at that time is 14% a year, compounded semi-annually,
what IRR did you earn?
{d} If the bond is called at the end of 6.5 years, what IRR did you
earn?
{e} If you convert the bond at the end of 6.5 years, what IRR did you
earn? Assume a common stock price of $29 a share.
{f} For part {d}, assume that Nylon can finance the call with a new
issue of 18.5 year bonds issued at par. They would carry an annual coupon
rate of 9% payable semi-annually. Legal fees would amount to an additional
$10 per bond. Calculate the NPV per bond of the decision to call.
[15] (30 points) SUPERGROWTH - EQUITY VALUATION Solution
Today you buy a $1,000 par value bond of the Kane Company. The annual
coupon rate is 8%, payable semiannually and the bond matures in 25 years.
The yield to maturity is 8.5% a year, compounded semiannually. The bond
is convertible into Kane’s common stock at a conversion price of $100 a
share.
Yesterday Kane paid a dividend per share of $2.50. The earnings and
dividends are expected to grow at 25% for the next 10 years before declining
to a 6% annual rate for the indefinite future.
{a} If common stock investors require an 18% return and you expect
the forecasts to hold, calculate the IRR of your investment if you expect
to convert the bond in 7 years.
{b} If the forecasts still hold and you keep the bond to maturity and
convert on the last day, what is your IRR? Why is this answer bigger or
smaller than part {a}?
[16] (30 points) SUPERGROWTH - EQUITY VALUATION Solution
Today you buy a $1,000 par value bond of Bunky’s Burgers for $950.
The bond pays an annual coupon rate of 8%, compounded semi-annually and
matures in 20 years. The bond is convertible into Bunky’s common stock
at a conversion price of $10 a share.
Yesterday Bunky’s paid a dividend per share of $7.60. The firm forecasts
that its earnings and dividends will decline at 20% a year for the next
5 years and then decline at 10% a year for another 4 years before stabilizing
at a positive growth rate of 5% a year for the indefinite future.
{a} If common stock investors require an 18% return and you expect
the forecasts to hold, calculate the IRR (expressed ss an EAR) of your
investment if you expect to convert the bond in 6 years.
{b} If the forecasts still hold and you keep the bond to maturity and
convert on the last day, what is your IRR (express as an EAR?
[17] (70 points) COST OF CAPITAL Solution
Huckleberry SmartPhones is planning its 2010 capital budget and needs
your advice. The firm believes that the capital structure relations shown
below are optimal and will be maintained.
Debt | $650,000,000 |
Preferred Stock | 100,000,000 |
Common Equity | 250,000,000 |
TOTAL CLAIMS |
The firm has a marginal tax rate of 40% and has $15,000,000 of retained
earnings available for investment this year. Huckleberry’s stock currently
has a dividend yield of 18% and its earnings and dividends are expected
to grow indefinitely at 8%.
The firm can raise funds under these conditions:
BONDS: Up to $13 million in new bonds can be issued to yield the investor
8% per year, compounded semi-annually. The annual coupon rate is 9% a year,
payable semiannually. The bonds have a par value of $1,000 and mature in
20 years. Flotation costs would be $48.96 per bond. An additional $26 million
of bonds would cost the firm a before-tax APR of 2.52% higher than the
first issue of bonds. Still another additional $26 million would have a
before-tax cost (APR) of 4.52% higher than the first issue of bonds. Any
additional bonds would have a before-tax cost (APR) of 7.52% above the
first issue of bonds.
PREFERRED STOCK: Any size issue can sold to net the firm $125 per share.
Par value is $100 and the dividend rate is 25% paid annually. The yield
to the investor is 17.24%.
COMMON STOCK: Any size issue can be sold with flotation costs and underpricing
equal to 20% of the current stock price.
The firm is considering six potential projects with the following forecasted
cash flows:
Project | Outlay ($millions) | IRR% |
A | 10 | 13.5 |
B | 25 | 19.0 |
C | 20 | 14.0 |
D | 25 | 17.0 |
E | 20 | 15.0 |
F | 20 | ?? |
{a} Compute Huckleberry’s marginal cost of capital for each segment
of the marginal cost schedule and display your results on a CLEARLY LABELED
graph.
{b} For project F, assume a life of 6 years and uniform annual cash
flows of $5.43 million. Calculate its IRR.
{c} On the same graph, plot the firm’s IRR schedule and indicate which
projects are acceptable. Compute the average cost of capital for the capital
budget you are advocating.
{d} For the preferred stock, calculate the flotation costs charged
by the underwriters.
{e} Calculate the NPV of project F. Clearly indicate your discount
rate.
(f) Why did Huckleberry accept projects whose IRR is less than the
required rate of return on their common stock?
{g} Draw and label the graph from the last lecture depicting what happens
to ke, ki and k0 as the level of debt increases. If the firm is currently
operating close to the right side of the optimal range, where are they
likely to get their next increase in capital from and why?
[18] (70 points) COST OF CAPITAL Solution
Psyleron is planning its forthcoming capital budget and needs your
advice. The firm believes that the capital structure relations shown below
are optimal and will be maintained.
Debt | $200,000,000 |
Preferred Stock | 100,000,000 |
Common Equity | 200,000,000 |
TOTAL CLAIMS | $500,000,000 |
The firm has a marginal tax rate of 40% and has $20,000,000 of retained
earnings available for investment this year. Three years ago Psyleron paid
a common stock dividend of $5.513 per share and yesterday it paid one of
$6.944. Assume this rate of growth continues for the indefinite future.
The common stock is currently trading for $75 a share.
The firm can raise funds under these conditions:
BONDS: Up to $20 million in new 25-year $1,000 par bonds can be issued
with an annual yield to maturity of 10.32%, compounded semiannually. The
annual coupon rate is 12% a year, payable semiannually. Flotation costs
would be $64.98 per bond. Any additional bonds would have an annual after-tax
cost of 1.8% higher than the first $20 million.
PREFERRED STOCK: New $50 par value preferred stock can be issued with
an annual dividend of 16% to produce an annual yield of 12%. The first
$25 million requires flotation costs of $9.53 and anything beyond that
requires flotation costs of $19.61 per share.
COMMON STOCK: Up to $30 million can be sold with flotation costs of
$25 a share. Any additional shares would require flotation costs of $30.82.
The firm is considering five potential projects with the following
forecasted cash flows (assume a 5-year life for all projects):
Project | Outlay ($millions) | IRR% |
A | 25 | 18% |
B | 35 | 16% |
C | 25 | ?? |
D | 35 | 15% |
E | 50 | 17% |
{a} Compute Psyleron’s marginal cost of capital for each segment of
the marginal cost schedule and display your results on a CLEARLY LABELED
graph.
{b} For project C, assume a life uniform annual cash flows of $7.11
million. Calculate its IRR.
{c} On the same graph, plot the firm’s IRR schedule and indicate which
projects are acceptable. Compute the average cost of capital for the capital
budget you are advocating.
{d} Calculate the NPV of project E. Clearly indicate your discount
rate.
(e) Why did Psyleron reject a project whose IRR is greater than the
average cost of capital found in {c}?
Selected Answers to Problems
[1A] LOAN A: i = 1.00% per month, EAR + 12.68% Total funds repaid = $126,402; LOAN B: i = .9487% per month, EAR = 12.00%, Total fund repaid = $131,402; Choose LOAN B *
[1B] EAR = -.18, x = 1.64% decline *
[3] D = $20,000; Planned W = $52,375.33; pot at 2010 = $1,424,594; X = $105,525
[5] CF=162, outlay = 750 - .6MV, MV = $112.88
[6] deltaD=.1X-50, BVold=480, deltaCF = 70+.04X, outlay = X-300, proceeds sale old = 372, X=827.39
[15] Price of bond = $948.52, Price of stock (year 7) = $165.35 so conversion value is $1653.51, IRR over 7 yrs = 7.42% per period or 14.83% per year, Price of stock year 25 = $492.89 and IRR = 5.77% per period or 11.55% per year
[17] Break points: debt 20, 60 and 100; equity 60; component costs debt 8.48% per year or 5.1% after tax, 6.6%, 7.8%, 9.6% (all after-tax); preferred 20% ({d} flotation costs on preferred =$20 per share), retained earnings 26% and common stock 30.5%, marginal costs: (0-20) 11.8%, (20-60) 12.8%, (60-100) 14.7% and (100+) 15.9%; accept B, D, F and E and raise $90 million at an ACC of 13.2%; IRR of F = 16.0%; NPV of F = $1.26 million using a discount rate of 13.75%
[7] s = 76.68 DCF=430; proceeds sale = 354; IRR = 40.89%; DCF = 406; IRR=47.61%
[11] i = 7.69%/period; EAR=15.98%; APR = 15.39%; P8 = $834.55; rb = 7.38% per period; rc = 8.27%; rd = 8.42%/periods; i = 6.42%/periods; APR=12.83%
[14] yield = 4/48.50= 8.25%, PCS,6 = 37.85; PCS,10 = 48.76; r = 4.3795% per quarter; r = 17.52%; PCS,12 = 53.76;
[15] Break points: Debt = $20 and $30; Equity = $30 and $50; Component costs: Debt = 3.9%, 5.0%, 6.1%; Pf'd stock = 15.0%; Equity = 15.5%, 18.0%, 20.0%; Accept C-A-D-E and raise $35 million at an ACC of 10.0%; yield on Pf'd Stock = 12.5%; Project D: CF = $3,285,413, kD = 10.85%; NPVD = $225,545
[16] Break points: Debt = $30; Preferred = $50; Equity = $30 and $50; Component costs: Debt = 6.0%, 7.2%; Pf'd stock = 12.9%, 15.0%; Equity = 17%, 20.0%, 23.0%; Accept C-B-A and raise $45 million at an ACC of 10.03%; Project D: CF = $3,817,386, kD = 11.655%; NPV=-802,443 NPVD = $225,545; {a} Price o>f bonds = $795,60; {b} flotation costs = $17.50